Children |
| 1. Mae Jane Maria Butterfield, b. 22 Oct 1817, Benson, Rutland, Vermont d. 19 Feb 1911, Dunkirk, Chautauqua, New York (Age 93 years) |
| 2. Deborah Ann Butterfield, b. 26 Mar 1819, Benson, Rutland, Vermont d. Yes, date unknown |
| 3. Nathan Butterfield, Jr., b. 10 Oct 1820, Benson, Rutland, Vermont d. Yes, date unknown |
+ | 4. William R. Butterfield, b. 27 Dec 1821, Benson, Rutland, Vermont d. Abt 1895, Cowley County, Kansas (Age 73 years) |
| 5. Ebenezer Butterfield, b. 12 Feb 1824, Benson, Rutland, Vermont d. Abt 1880 (Age 55 years) |
| 6. Walter Chipman Butterfield, b. 2 Jul 1826, Benson, Rutland, Vermont d. Abt 1835 (Age 8 years) |
| 7. Sarah Octavia "Sally" Butterfield, b. 14 Sep 1828, Benson, Rutland, Vermont d. 27 Dec 1907, Dunkirk, Chautauqua, New York (Age 79 years) |
| 8. Chloe Butterfield, b. 9 Dec 1830, Benson, Rutland, Vermont d. 17 Mar 1854 (Age 23 years) |
| 9. Orena Butterfield, b. 2 Jan 1835, Whitehall, Washington, New York d. 9 Dec 1907, Redlands, San Bernardino, California (Age 72 years) |
| 10. Hiram E. Butterfield, b. Aug 1837, New York d. Yes, date unknown |
| 11. Jane Mary Butterfield, b. 9 Jun 1839, Whitehall, Washington, New York d. Yes, date unknown, Jamestown, Chautauqua, New York |
| 12. Samuel Draper Butterfield, b. Abt 1843, Pomfret Twp, Chautauqua, New York d. Yes, date unknown |
|